Jump to content



Photo
- - - - -

12v Solenoid vs contactor

solenoid contactor flipper

  • Please log in to reply
90 replies to this topic

#61 kiwiBri

kiwiBri

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 369 posts
  • Location:Ontario, Canada

  • Flag: Canada

  • Favorite Pinball: STNG/TAF/IJ

Posted 29 May 2017 - 08:05 PM

 

Thanks for the videos!   So you're using contactors but no solenoids for pop bumpers and slingshots right?   Thinking I might just pull the trigger and get them and see how they work.


I haven't finished my cab yet, so im just testing this outside of the cab with a 12v power supply. I'll be using these 12v solenoids for pop bumpers and slingshots, but for the flippers i'll be using contactors.

 

 

How did the contactors work out for the flippers ? Did you get 24v or manage to find 12v contactors?


I plan to use these 12v solenoids for my build - for the slings/pops and flippers. For those that are using the 12v solenoids for flippers, how do they "feel" or sound?


Completed: (For now ;) )  - My 46/30/DMD Judge Dredd Cab Build


#62 Thalamus

Thalamus

    VPF Veteran

  • Platinum Supporter
  • 5,008 posts

  • Flag: Norway

  • Favorite Pinball: GOT, Alien Star, LOTR, TOM

Posted 29 May 2017 - 08:40 PM

I have the zeb kit and it consist of all solenoids. I don't like so much the fact that the flippers sounds almost the same as the slings. ( slightly different only because of location ) I think I will cut out some thick wool or something and use that to muffle the sound a bit. Feel ? Hmm ... don't know how to answer that.


From now on. I won't help anyone here at VPF. Please ask Noah why that is.


#63 STV

STV

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 436 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Varies. 140 in the list ATM.

Posted 30 May 2017 - 03:36 AM

I did 12V solenoids for bumpers/targets.  Turned down to ~8.5V via some voltage regulator.
Then put in two different pairs of 24V contactors for flippers/slings.  The different types give just a bit of different feel between them.   
 
FTW


#64 jesperpark

jesperpark

    Enthusiast

  • Silver Supporter
  • 271 posts
  • Location:Edmonton Alberta Canada

  • Flag: Canada

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 30 May 2017 - 04:05 AM

I am using 10 solenoids along with zebs board.  I first had 8 solenoids and 2 contactors for the flippers, i found the contactors were not responsive enough for my tastes.  If i hit the flipper twice then the contactor would not register the second sound, that said i may of had contactors to large and therefore slow to respond.  A downside to a solenoid is you hear/feel a clunk on the flipper button press, then another on the release.  It used to bug me at first, but then i forgot all about it until i started writing this...maybe time to find 2 smaller contactors and try them out.  Honestly other than the flipper double clunk I'm quite happy with solenoids especially with the cheaper cost of them.



#65 GInsonic

GInsonic

    Enthusiast

  • Platinum Supporter
  • 188 posts

  • Flag: Austria

  • Favorite Pinball: Addams Family

Posted 30 May 2017 - 09:03 AM

I use ten of these:

 

https://www.sparkfun.../products/10391

 

IMO they sound much more realistic than the usual SIEMENS contactors (had them before).

 

 

 

I don't like so much the fact that the flippers sounds almost the same as the slings

 

@Thalamus: Indeed, but I resolved this issue and created (3D printing) different holders, where the "impact plate" can be replaced. For the bumpers I used metal screws, for the flippers plastic parts !

 

Please see: http://www.vpforums....393#entry351647



#66 STV

STV

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 436 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Varies. 140 in the list ATM.

Posted 30 May 2017 - 02:24 PM

I mounted the sling contactors on the walls of the cabinet, while the flipper contactors are on a 1x2" piece of wood that spans the cabinet.  So those lie physically below about where the flippers would.   Makes for a good contrast between the pairs.   



#67 kiwiBri

kiwiBri

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 369 posts
  • Location:Ontario, Canada

  • Flag: Canada

  • Favorite Pinball: STNG/TAF/IJ

Posted 30 May 2017 - 04:04 PM

I have the zeb kit and it consist of all solenoids. I don't like so much the fact that the flippers sounds almost the same as the slings. ( slightly different only because of location ) I think I will cut out some thick wool or something and use that to muffle the sound a bit. Feel ? Hmm ... don't know how to answer that.

 

thanks.. yes, I was thinking of doing that too.. change the sound up somewhat. I can see there will be a lot of removing glass and TV back and forth when trying to dial these in :)

 

 

 

I did 12V solenoids for bumpers/targets.  Turned down to ~8.5V via some voltage regulator.
Then put in two different pairs of 24V contactors for flippers/slings.  The different types give just a bit of different feel between them.   
 
FTW

 

 

Interesting.. didnt think to vary the voltage. Might be an option.

 

 

I am using 10 solenoids along with zebs board.  I first had 8 solenoids and 2 contactors for the flippers, i found the contactors were not responsive enough for my tastes.  If i hit the flipper twice then the contactor would not register the second sound, that said i may of had contactors to large and therefore slow to respond.  A downside to a solenoid is you hear/feel a clunk on the flipper button press, then another on the release.  It used to bug me at first, but then i forgot all about it until i started writing this...maybe time to find 2 smaller contactors and try them out.  Honestly other than the flipper double clunk I'm quite happy with solenoids especially with the cheaper cost of them.

 

The double flipper thunk has been addressed if you are using the Pinscape boards. MJR has added the capability for devices to be configured to be fired and released even when you keep button pressed. I have tested this and it works fantastic!!!

 

Check it out:

 

 

 

I use ten of these:

 

https://www.sparkfun.../products/10391

 

IMO they sound much more realistic than the usual SIEMENS contactors (had them before).

 

 

 

I don't like so much the fact that the flippers sounds almost the same as the slings

 

@Thalamus: Indeed, but I resolved this issue and created (3D printing) different holders, where the "impact plate" can be replaced. For the bumpers I used metal screws, for the flippers plastic parts !

 

Please see: http://www.vpforums....393#entry351647

 

WOW! 36v solenoids! :)

 

 

I mounted the sling contactors on the walls of the cabinet, while the flipper contactors are on a 1x2" piece of wood that spans the cabinet.  So those lie physically below about where the flippers would.   Makes for a good contrast between the pairs.   

 

 

thanks for all the comments and feedback. I think it's going to be a trial an error thing when I get up to the final stages.


Edited by kiwiBri, 30 May 2017 - 04:10 PM.

Completed: (For now ;) )  - My 46/30/DMD Judge Dredd Cab Build


#68 wrd1972

wrd1972

    Authoring Padawan

  • Platinum Supporter
  • 2,265 posts
  • Location:Central KY. USA

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Funhouse

Posted 30 May 2017 - 06:31 PM

Ford 12V truck starter solenoids here. They feel and sound realistic but do wear out over time and need to be replaced. Ive worn out my welcome at the local Advance Auto Parts store using the lifetime warranties. :)


My VP Pincab /MAME Arcade  Specs: Dell T3400 workstation with Core2 Quad core 3.0GHZ (Q9650) CPU - 8GB of RAM - Nvidia  GTX 970

40" PF Sony gaming LED TV, Dual 21" Dell monitors in the backbox - Pinscape dual boards - Full DOF - Full MAME arcade support.


#69 kiwiBri

kiwiBri

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 369 posts
  • Location:Ontario, Canada

  • Flag: Canada

  • Favorite Pinball: STNG/TAF/IJ

Posted 30 May 2017 - 07:05 PM

Ford 12V truck starter solenoids here. They feel and sound realistic but do wear out over time and need to be replaced. Ive worn out my welcome at the local Advance Auto Parts store using the lifetime warranties. :)

 

Are you using them for flippers or all devices?  How long did they last?


Completed: (For now ;) )  - My 46/30/DMD Judge Dredd Cab Build


#70 wrd1972

wrd1972

    Authoring Padawan

  • Platinum Supporter
  • 2,265 posts
  • Location:Central KY. USA

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Funhouse

Posted 30 May 2017 - 07:59 PM

I use them for flippers, pop-bumpers, slings, holes, kickers, Dt target reset etc. Nothing for spot targets...but rather sound there. Flippers take the biggest beating for obvious reasons. They do last a good while though and are dirt cheap ($8 on ebay) to replace. I have never tried anything else I guess because ive been very happy with these.


My VP Pincab /MAME Arcade  Specs: Dell T3400 workstation with Core2 Quad core 3.0GHZ (Q9650) CPU - 8GB of RAM - Nvidia  GTX 970

40" PF Sony gaming LED TV, Dual 21" Dell monitors in the backbox - Pinscape dual boards - Full DOF - Full MAME arcade support.


#71 kiwiBri

kiwiBri

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 369 posts
  • Location:Ontario, Canada

  • Flag: Canada

  • Favorite Pinball: STNG/TAF/IJ

Posted 31 May 2017 - 01:19 PM

I have the zeb kit and it consist of all solenoids. I don't like so much the fact that the flippers sounds almost the same as the slings. ( slightly different only because of location ) I think I will cut out some thick wool or something and use that to muffle the sound a bit. Feel ? Hmm ... don't know how to answer that.


Does his kit use automotive solenoids?

I plan to use L brackets to strike the solenoids against. L bracket will have material like rubber, wood or plastic to try and alternate sound.. I hope!

Sent from my SM-G935W8 using Tapatalk

I am using 10 solenoids along with zebs board.  I first had 8 solenoids and 2 contactors for the flippers, i found the contactors were not responsive enough for my tastes.  If i hit the flipper twice then the contactor would not register the second sound, that said i may of had contactors to large and therefore slow to respond.  A downside to a solenoid is you hear/feel a clunk on the flipper button press, then another on the release.  It used to bug me at first, but then i forgot all about it until i started writing this...maybe time to find 2 smaller contactors and try them out.  Honestly other than the flipper double clunk I'm quite happy with solenoids especially with the cheaper cost of them.


24v contactors or the elusive 12v ones?

Sent from my SM-G935W8 using Tapatalk

Completed: (For now ;) )  - My 46/30/DMD Judge Dredd Cab Build


#72 BritXpatUSA

BritXpatUSA

    Hobbyist

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 48 posts

  • Flag: United Kingdom

  • Favorite Pinball: wizard

  • 360 Gamer Tag: BritXpatUSA

Posted 31 May 2017 - 01:58 PM

hi all, been lurking on a few threads now with trying to do my build also.

I have ford starters for my toys 10 of them...now i had 8.

i need help and hoping someone can answer give some pointers!

i used the sainsmart 8 relay usb and got all working....i have now bought a 16 way relay and added on usb board...but for the life of me i cannot get it to work.

im on windows 10 and i shows the board as a HID device, i have tried the relay program but it wont pick it up. 

Anyone have any pointers to get the board working? I also have a iPAQ Ultimate I/O board that runs buttons, spinner so i dont know if you can wire the relay board to this?

picture of the boards, 

thanks in advance!

 

https://www.dropbox....DQhTSY87Ma?dl=0

 

 

Edited by BritXpatUSA, 31 May 2017 - 01:59 PM.


#73 Outhere

Outhere

    Pinball Wizard

  • Platinum Supporter
  • 4,807 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: M M

Posted 31 May 2017 - 03:17 PM

I do not believe the 16 relay board with the USB adapter will work with Windows at all...
I do not think either boards will work with the dof....

http://pinball.weile...P/hardware.html

you can use 2  sainsmart 8 relay boards or I believe you could buy an LED Wiz and use your 16 relay board

2  sainsmart 8 relay xml

http://www.vpforums....927#entry308671

LED Wiz and use your 16 relay board

http://www.vpforums....topic=29692&hl=


Edited by Outhere, 31 May 2017 - 03:54 PM.


#74 wrd1972

wrd1972

    Authoring Padawan

  • Platinum Supporter
  • 2,265 posts
  • Location:Central KY. USA

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Funhouse

Posted 31 May 2017 - 03:21 PM

16 relay is not supported per Arngrim. Need to use dual 8's.


My VP Pincab /MAME Arcade  Specs: Dell T3400 workstation with Core2 Quad core 3.0GHZ (Q9650) CPU - 8GB of RAM - Nvidia  GTX 970

40" PF Sony gaming LED TV, Dual 21" Dell monitors in the backbox - Pinscape dual boards - Full DOF - Full MAME arcade support.


#75 BritXpatUSA

BritXpatUSA

    Hobbyist

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 48 posts

  • Flag: United Kingdom

  • Favorite Pinball: wizard

  • 360 Gamer Tag: BritXpatUSA

Posted 31 May 2017 - 04:23 PM

thanks guys....appreciate the replys....I have a spare octo board  from zeb so may just use that then....

at least im not going crazy try to get it to work...

i di manage to get it firing the relay on a test laptop rig....

found this info in Chinese and good old good to translate and managed to  just now open close relay.....

 

 

03/05/15  04:31    <DIR>          .
03/05/15  04:31    <DIR>          ..
11/20/14  04:18            11,264 CommandApp_USBRelay.exe
11/20/14  04:29            75,776 GuiApp_English.exe
11/04/14  02:47               992 manual.txt
07/10/11  22:57         4,422,992 mfc100u.dll
01/18/13  09:37           799,232 XCGUI.dll
               5 File(s)      5,310,256 bytes
               2 Dir(s)  256,251,633,664 bytes free
ran this command:
 
Pinball working files\HID-relay\16 relay>CommandApp_USBRelay  afEd5 open 01
 
looks like the devise serial is the same for all?
 
the gui crashes on my system also....
 
ARNGRIM.....can you add to the config tool? pls...:-)
 
thx

Edited by BritXpatUSA, 31 May 2017 - 04:24 PM.


#76 STV

STV

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 436 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Varies. 140 in the list ATM.

Posted 31 May 2017 - 05:08 PM

Concurring that the ss16 isn't workable by itself.  I have one and use the LEDWIZ in front of it to switch the relays



#77 BritXpatUSA

BritXpatUSA

    Hobbyist

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 48 posts

  • Flag: United Kingdom

  • Favorite Pinball: wizard

  • 360 Gamer Tag: BritXpatUSA

Posted 01 June 2017 - 12:44 AM

Concurring that the ss16 isn't workable by itself.  I have one and use the LEDWIZ in front of it to switch the relays

thanks!

I do have a iPAQ Ultimate IO board so im looking to see if i can use this infront of the 16 port relay. i have emailed Andy to see if i can...

Ive also ordered a second 8 port usb....



#78 rambo3

rambo3

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 53 posts

  • Flag: Norway

  • Favorite Pinball: Attack from Mars!

Posted 01 June 2017 - 08:31 PM

Absolutely, it's what I do for my contactors. UIO is absolutely amazing, it is such a nice piece of single-device input+outputs.

 

I've got 10 of the UIO outputs wired to a 16 port SainSmart, then wired to 10 contactors.

 

I'm not sure what you're using to drive the UIO. If you're using DOF you'll need the one with UIO support I did some time ago (backup your DOF-directory before doing so), and setup an UIO on configtool.

https://github.com/r...ctOutput/Builds

 

I've since added Philips Hue and ScheduledSettings support to it. The UIO is...such a great board.

 

Forgot to add; I too have the 8-port USB version. Not my favorite to be honest. For one; it'll active / reset all outputs on boot. That's one mighty bang. Nothing harmful, it's just ...loud when 8 contactors hit at the same time. Consider yourself warned :) I removed mine in favor of the 16 port.

 

Forgot to add: thread here on DOF and UIO
http://www.vpforums....showtopic=36187


Edited by rambo3, 01 June 2017 - 08:34 PM.


#79 BritXpatUSA

BritXpatUSA

    Hobbyist

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 48 posts

  • Flag: United Kingdom

  • Favorite Pinball: wizard

  • 360 Gamer Tag: BritXpatUSA

Posted 05 June 2017 - 09:20 PM

Absolutely, it's what I do for my contactors. UIO is absolutely amazing, it is such a nice piece of single-device input+outputs.

 

I've got 10 of the UIO outputs wired to a 16 port SainSmart, then wired to 10 contactors.

 

I'm not sure what you're using to drive the UIO. If you're using DOF you'll need the one with UIO support I did some time ago (backup your DOF-directory before doing so), and setup an UIO on configtool.

https://github.com/r...ctOutput/Builds

 

I've since added Philips Hue and ScheduledSettings support to it. The UIO is...such a great board.

 

Forgot to add; I too have the 8-port USB version. Not my favorite to be honest. For one; it'll active / reset all outputs on boot. That's one mighty bang. Nothing harmful, it's just ...loud when 8 contactors hit at the same time. Consider yourself warned :) I removed mine in favor of the 16 port.

 

Forgot to add: thread here on DOF and UIO
http://www.vpforums....showtopic=36187

hey thanks for the reply :-)....ive been away and just back home.....so now i have two usb 8 ports and a 16 port.....:-) any chance you can help with the wiring, pics/diagram or port to port, pls?

I have a shaker from Zeb just arrived...so looking to use the U I/O for all the buttons/joys....mines a hybrid build so two joysticks/usual flippers and extra buttons. 

I have two leds flashers and a led beacon all 12V - i was going to put to the relays but told this is not good so presume these will go to the LEDs on the U I/O board.

then i have Prog LEDS going to a teensy...will have one each side of cab and then a 8 strip board at the back - 

power supplies galore interdependent 12v and 5v plus a powerful PC...

I have put VR ports on the front to plug in my vive also so can do VR using the flipper buttons....and the powerful PC 108o GC card etc.

Sains 16 ports for the solenoids & shaker only?

 

Im interested in your HUE....but im way over already so time to take a check pace....I have smarthings smarthub all over the house/garden with leds and bulbs...

Im only home for a few days before im off traveling again...so ill see what i can do....

thanks!



#80 rambo3

rambo3

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 53 posts

  • Flag: Norway

  • Favorite Pinball: Attack from Mars!

Posted 09 June 2017 - 06:32 AM

The UIO outputs are low power, about 20mA at 12V I think? I highly recommend just clicking my profile and just check my posts as I asked alot of questions on this and got alot of help. I'm a programmer at heart, not electrician :)

 

I think it can do 12V bulbs, got some laying around, but eventually replaced them with LEDs to avoid overheating inside the actual buttons. Less heat. I wouldn't use the UIO outputs for flashers (which can take up over 350mA) or a LED beacon (which probably needs power for motor too?). So what you can do is use the UIO outputs as "trigger signals" to the SainSmart, and then have a SainSmart a single relay powered externally to for instance a flasher or say 24V contactor. Now multiply that with say 10 contactors and 1 set of flashers. Your 16-relay board still has available inputs/outputs. It isn't perfect, as the SainSmart introduces a ~100ms lag and just does on/off, but it's a start.

 

I highly recommend you start slow. For instance, just plug in your UIO and SainSmart USB (and nothing on it, just the device, USB connection, and power to it), go to configtool, setup up a SainSmart (left+right flippers, left and right slingshots), and see if you get anything. If you do, you know DOF and your table setup is running.

 

Then hook up a few LEDs to your UIO outputs, add an UIO to configtool, setup two outputs to say a left and right flippers, and try again. If that works, you'll know the UIO also works with DOF.

 

Two recommendations: 1) the UIO has a nice startup color output cycling, which means technically output cycling. It's cool for LEDs, but once you got your stuff connected it'll also trigger contactors, shakers, anything that the outputs are connected to. You can use one of the Ultimarc tools (winipac?) to set reset / blank that color cycling to none at boot / power on. And 2) the SainSmart 8 port USB also does this, except you can't turn off output cycling AND it does it 2 or three times. Maybe there's some way to update it or modify it, but right now I'm using the non-USB boards myself as they don't output cycle at poweron.


Edited by rambo3, 09 June 2017 - 06:33 AM.