Jump to content



Photo
- - - - -

Siemens Contactors weak strike due to PWM modulation issue on PinScape Power Board?


  • Please log in to reply
15 replies to this topic

#1 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 05 September 2026 - 09:56 AM

Hello everyone,

 

I have a 10-Bumper system consisting of 6 SW3-type solenoids for the Back Bumpers and Mid Bumpers, and 4 Siemens Sirius 3RH1140-1BB40 contactors for the Slingshots and Flippers. They are controlled by a KL25Z over PinScape and connected to the PWM outputs of the PinScape Power Board expansion card.

 

The SW3 solenoids are daisy-chained to the 12V (maximum output current of 59A) of a Mars Gaming MPVU750M as a secondary PSU. The Siemens contactors are daisy-chained to the 24V (4.5A) S-100F-24 Meanwell PSU. The grounds (GND) of both power supplies are tied together but isolated from the PC's PSU. All devices are fitted with their corresponding 1N4007 diode to prevent flyback voltage, using 18AWG wiring, except for the signal lines which are 22AWG to fit into the Dupont connectors for the 0.1" pin headers.

 

When tested manually, all devices work properly and deliver a solid click sound. However, once integrated into the system, testing via either the PinScape Output Tester or in-game through DOF yields poor results: all SW3 solenoids fire and sound correctly, but the contactors respond with almost inaudible or low-to-mid intensity strikes.

 

The manufacturer indicates that the required reaction time for the spring ranges between 30ms and 100ms. I have configured the Flipper Logic in PinScape for the contactors with an Initial Time of up to 250ms and 100% Hold Power. I even tried PinScape's Chime Logic with a Minimum ON Time of 100ms and a Maximum ON Time of 250ms. I also applied the following parameters in the DOF Config Tool under Variables --> Contactor: Target Duration: 180, Target Intensity: 48.

 

While testing during gameplay, I held down one of the flippers and captured the pulse with an oscilloscope. I observed a pulse lasting about 150ms before returning to its rest state. However, the waveform showed small, full rising and falling edges throughout its duration—resembling multiple modulated pulses rather than a single, clean 150ms pulse.

 

Any ideas on what might be happening?

 

Can some of the outputs to the power board be configured to operate digitally? If so, how? That could be a possible solution.

 

Any clues or help will be highly appreciated. Thank you very much in advance.



#2 mjr

mjr

    Pinball Wizard

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,346 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 05 September 2026 - 05:39 PM

The power board outputs should be equivalent to digital outputs (i.e., they'll output a true 100% duty cycle) when commanded to turn on at 100%, so a "digital" option isn't necessary.

 

I suspect you have something, somewhere in the output chain that's commanding the ports to a PWM value below 100%.  I'd start by turning off everything optional in the output port configuration - Flipper Logic and Chime Logic, 'source' formulas, etc.  You don't need anything like flipper logic or chime logic to physically protect contactors, since contactors are designed to be energized indefinitely.   And do your initial testing through the Config Tool "Output Hardware" window, which bypasses most of the host-side logic that could be setting lower PWM rates.



#3 mjr

mjr

    Pinball Wizard

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,346 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 05 September 2026 - 05:50 PM

I should make sure we're talking about the same thing here - are you on the KL25Z or Pico version of Pinscape?  My answer above might be a bit confusing if you're on KL25Z.



#4 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 06 September 2026 - 08:23 AM

Hi mjr,
 
It is a pleasure and an excitement to discuss this matter with you. Clearly, there is no one better than you to help me with this situation.
 
First, I can confirm that I am using the KL25Z (Firmware 2024-10-05-2011) on the PinScape system (EU version of the Main, Power, and Chime Boards). Although I was very tempted to switch to the Pico version due to the TLC5940 shortage, which forced me to design adapter PCBs for both the 32-Pin VQFN and 28-Pin HTSSOP packages so I could assemble and solder them myself. In part, this has delayed the testing.
 
Another handicap I have had to deal with, and the main reason why my cabinet build has taken so long, is that I am building it at a house I only visit during vacations and occasionally on weekends. Consequently, this also means it will likely take me some time to provide feedback on your suggestions, so I kindly ask for your understanding.
 
I completely understand what you mean regarding the Power Board outputs; that aligns exactly with my understanding. I have been building my cabinet for 5 years with all kinds of toys, but due to the TLC5940 shortage and the detailed descriptions in your "bible," I hadn't felt the need or concern to test the outputs beforehand. The only ones I did test were for the chimes and the bell (Small, Large, and Topper) connected to the Chime Board —which work flawlessly— since I used AliExpress solenoids (12V JF-0530B) that required custom 3D-printed mounts. Therefore, I went ahead and built the entire system, assuming it would practically be plug-and-play. This past July, when I finally sourced a complete set of TLC5940s and began the final assembly and testing of the overall PinScape system, the contactor issue was the only fault I noticed. It is possible that the same reduced pulse is being sent to the motor, shaker, and blower (which are also connected to the Power Board), but if so, their behavior seems correct, just like with the SW3 solenoids. However, I could analyze this further with an oscilloscope.
 
Finally, to answer your question, yes, I perform the hardware testing primarily through the Config Tool "Output Hardware" window. However, as you rightly pointed out, something must be preventing the signal from being sent correctly. Out of desperation, that is why I resorted to testing with Flipper Logic, Chime Logic, thinking about digital outputs, and even considering adding a monostable circuit to the output which is obviously completely unnecessary, but you can understand how eager I am to see the system finished.
 
Throughout all this time, I have read and re-read your "bible," but I don't understand what you mean by 'source' formulas.
 
Please excuse me if I am writing too much; I just want to provide as much information and context as possible.
 
Thanks again.


#5 mjr

mjr

    Pinball Wizard

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,346 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 06 September 2026 - 10:42 PM

Ah, okay, KL25Z then.  What I said about the "source" formula only applies to the Pico version, so sorry about the confusion there.  And it also explains the scope waveform you're seeing.  The TLC5940 chips can't achieve quite 100% duty cycle on the physical output, even at a nominal 100% PWM rate, because they have a short "off" period in each cycle even at 100% PWM rate.  But the "off" period is VERY short, less than about one part in 1000, so the power reduction it causes should truly be trivial - the effective RMS power level is probably something like 99.8 or 99.9 percent.  Not enough of a reduction that you should see ANY effect at all, let alone such a dramatic effect as you're seeing.  But since you're scoping it, you should be able to see exactly what the timing figures look like - does the little "off" period per cycle look as short as I'm saying, or are you seeing a more significant reduction in overall duty cycle than that?

 

Unfortunately, the PWM behavior is a hardware feature of those chips, so there's no way to configure them into "digital" mode.  If the physical PWM cycle is at 99+% like I'm expecting, and that's enough to cause this reduction in power, maybe there's some kind of frequency-based interaction with those particular contactors - some kind of inductive filter effect or something like that.  I wouldn't expect that, but it might explain why the problem is only affecting the contactors and not the other similar devices you're also using.  If you're seeing significantly less than 99% duty cycle on the scope signal, that's something to look into further.

 

Assuming the duty cycle looks good, one random idea you might try is adding a ceramic disc capacitor into the mix, to try to smooth out the physical PWM signal.  Something like 0.1 uF, placed across the contactor terminals, in parallel with the diode.  I'm not sure that would help, and I'm not sure what size capacitor would be best - if you don't see any difference at 0.1 uF, you could also try 1 uF.


Edited by mjr, 06 September 2026 - 10:45 PM.


#6 fhjui

fhjui

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 383 posts
  • Location:Germany

  • Flag: Germany

  • Favorite Pinball: especially EM tables

Posted 08 September 2026 - 09:55 PM

That’s a rather strange error.

I would recommend measuring the individual stages of the circuit.

It’s been a few years since I worked with the KL25Z. I wasn't aware that this IC couldn't produce a 100% DC output—I hadn't noticed that during my own measurements—but it doesn't affect proper operation at all.

Back then, I wrote an explanation of how the various stages of the PinScape outputs work; it’s a bit more detailed than MJR’s guide. You can find that document in my cloud storage—specifically, the file "Troubleshooting the Pinscape board" in the "Pinscape Board" folder.

The link is in my footer.
When you press the flipper button, the output must remain low (outputs are switching to GND), meaning the contactor stays engaged. In the case of the chime board, the contactor drops out after about 2 seconds due to the hardware design involving the NE555 timer IC.

I would noct recommend starter soleonids because they aren't built for such frequent operation, they can overheat and they can fail after a short period. (1 year perhaps). Contactors, on the other hand, are designed for frequent and continuous operation.

Instead I would give a Siemens 3RT-1025 a try.

In the cloud folder "Build of Virtual Pinball Draft" you can find a draft docu of my VP build. But its not complete, written in german (you can translate important parts using AI) and very special for my hardware.But there are interesting chapters for you:

  • P.30: comparison of various contactors. Your Siemens contactor draws ~150mA, the starter soleonid ~2,3A. For that I would say your 59A PS is much oversized.
    In the event of a fault or short circuit, such currents cannot be managed without special protectives. In this case, the power supply must at least feature a foldback characteristic.
  • P.25: coice of a correct MOSFET. The usual pupulated ones have a too high Ron resistance for driving Gear- oder shakermotor. For that I have used a special one with very low Ron
    But for simple switching of contactors ttaht aspect isn't important

Edited by fhjui, 10 September 2026 - 06:41 PM.

My documentation for installing vpin software with PinUpsystem (Baller installer): https://mega.nz/fold...wAXZlOEMQGbdutQ

Files and PDF-docu in the subdir "Installation vPin-Software with Baller-Installer"


#7 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 09 September 2026 - 02:51 PM

 

That’s a rather strange error.

I would recommend measuring the individual stages of the circuit.

It’s been a few years since I worked with the KL25Z. I wasn't aware that this IC couldn't produce a 100% DC output—I hadn't noticed that during my own measurements—but it doesn't affect proper operation at all.

Back then, I wrote an explanation of how the various stages of the PinScape outputs work; it’s a bit more detailed than MJR’s guide. You can find that document in my cloud storage—specifically, the file "Troubleshooting the Pinscape board" in the "Pinscape Board" folder.

The link is in my footer.
When you press the flipper button, the output must remain high, meaning the contactor stays engaged. In the case of the chime board, the contactor drops out after about 2 seconds due to the hardware design involving the NE555 timer IC.

I would noct recommend starter soleonids because they aren't built for such frequent operation, they can overheat and they can fail after a short period. (1 year perhaps). Contactors, on the other hand, are designed for frequent and continuous operation.

Instead I would give a Siemens 3RT-1025 a try.

In the cloud folder "Build of Virtual Pinball Draft" you can find a draft docu of my VP build. But its not complete, written in german (you can translate important parts using AI) and very special for my hardware.But there are interesting chapters for you:

  • P.30: comparison of various contactors. Your Siemens contactor draws ~150mA, the starter soleonid ~2,3A. For that I would say your 59A PS is much oversized.
    In the event of a fault or short circuit, such currents cannot be managed without special protectives. In this case, the power supply must at least feature a foldback characteristic.
  • P.25: coice of a correct MOSFET. The usual pupulated ones have a too high Ron resistance for driving Gear- oder shakermotor. For that I have used a special one with very low Ron
    But for simple switching of contactors ttaht aspect isn't important

 

 

Hi fhjui,
 
Thank you for your help.
 
Regarding the starter solenoids, I completely agree with you. That is why at the beginning of the summer I bought a batch of different Siemens contactors to replace them with this configuration, trying to achieve different impact intensities depending on their location and purpose:
 
 (3RT1015-1BB42)        (3RT1015-1BB42)        (3RT1015-1BB42)
    Left Bumper               Center Bumper            Right Bumper
 
 --------------------------------------------------
 
    (3RT2017-1BB41)        (3RH1140-1BB40)        (3RT2017-1BB41)
    Left MID Bumper        Center MID Bumper     Right MID Bumper
 
 --------------------------------------------------
 
         (3RT2016-1BB41)                 (3RT2016-1BB41)
          Left Slingshot                       Right Slingshot
 
    (3RT2017-1BB41)                            (3RT2017-1BB41)
    Left Flipper                                       Right Flipper
 
But unfortunately, this issue has stalled me once again, and I am not going to proceed with the final assembly until I solve it.
 
Regarding the Mosfet mounted on the PinScape System, I would like to point out that I am using the FQPF30N06L. Do you think I should switch it to the IRFB4310Z?  That wouldn't be a problem.
 
It is true that the secondary Power Supply Unit is oversized, but it is not intentional; it was simply a PC power supply that I had on hand and used to power the TOYs. Since it is a mid-range PSU, it features built-in safety elements. Furthermore, except for the repeating Bell, Fan Blower, Shaker, and Gear, the rest of the 12V Toys are triggered through the Chime Board, which, as you correctly noted, has a protection mechanism. In any case, all Toys have an individually rated protective fuse, so I don't feel there is any risk regarding the Secondary PSU.
 
I am going to take a look at the documentation you mentioned. I will try to bring the entire PinScape System and the Contactor module home so I can take measurements and try to find the problem and solution more quickly. I hope to give you all some feedback in a couple of weeks.
 
Thanks again.


#8 fhjui

fhjui

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 383 posts
  • Location:Germany

  • Flag: Germany

  • Favorite Pinball: especially EM tables

Posted 10 September 2026 - 07:20 PM

I have seen that in my post above there was a careless mistake, the outputs are switching to GND, have corrected it.

It looks like you know your stuff. No you don't need to swap the MOSFETs, have read the data of the FQPF30N06, its is a logic level Trans. ,but has also a very low Ron. Thats ok.

For easier handling I have translated the draft docu with help of AI, that's quick results and saves a lot of time. Have uploaded it in my cloud space, "Project Virtual Pinball V7-EN.pdf".

 

yes, its a good idea to dismount the 2 pinscape pcbs and test them at home, without always lying waist-deep in the pinball machine. ( I know that)

I had made a simple test board for testing the pinscape ICs and trans with help of a small and simple arduino program and a bread board. You can find the whole stuff in the dir. "Pinscapeboard\Testboard"


My documentation for installing vpin software with PinUpsystem (Baller installer): https://mega.nz/fold...wAXZlOEMQGbdutQ

Files and PDF-docu in the subdir "Installation vPin-Software with Baller-Installer"


#9 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 29 September 2026 - 08:40 PM

Hello again.
I am back with more information in the form of signal data.
 
First, I have attached a link to my Drive, which contains short videos showing the oscilloscope signal and the sound of the contactor when manually activated for both the Left Flipper (3RT2017-1BB41) and the Left SlingShot (3RT2016-1BB41). This should provide a clear acoustic reference for both contactors.
 
Below, I have included an image capturing the oscilloscope reading of a pulse via PinScape for both the Left Flipper and the Left SlingShot during a very weak strike.
 
Additionally, I am including a video of both the Left Flipper and the Left SlingShot under continuous activation (simulating a held button) via PinScape. You can observe different behaviors here, and hear that they fail to keep the contact closed. In the case of the Flipper, it activates with an acceptable sound and holds for a while before finally dropping. As for the SlingShot, the initial strike is also acceptable, but it barely holds the contact at all.
 
I have also included a pulse test via PinScape (quick activation-deactivation), where the Flipper's strike seems acceptable — though noticeably weaker than during manual activation — while the SlingShot's strike is very weak.
 
In any case, the general behavior of the contactors is erratic. Sometimes they sound good, other times they don't make any sound, and other times they click very weakly.
 
Lastly, I am providing videos showing the response of the starter solenoids, where you can hear a good acoustic and motor-like response.
 
 
I hope all this material is helpful.


#10 mjr

mjr

    Pinball Wizard

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,346 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 30 September 2026 - 02:58 AM

I'm afraid I don't see anything there that jumps out as explaining the problem.  It's pretty hard to interpret a video of an oscilloscope trace, though.  One thing you might try is connecting a small load in place of the contactor, like a small LED, and compare the traces.  Likewise, you could try a different inductive device that doesn't have the same weakness problem.  If there's something that stands out to you as unique about the contactor trace, maybe that's the thing to look at more closely, and by the same token, if they all look more or less the same, maybe the problem lies somewhere other than the PWM signal shape.


Sorry I don't have any better insights - this just seems like a weird problem that I don't know what to make of.


The simplest solution at this point might be to ditch those contactors and try something else.


(Although I'll admit that if this were my cab, I'd probably get obsessed with getting to the bottom of it.  But I would expect that to be a lengthy hands-on debugging exercise, so it would be a deliberate decision not to go the simple route.)



#11 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 30 September 2026 - 01:28 PM

Don't worry, mjr, I really appreciate your interest and dedication.
 
However, regarding testing with a different inductive device, the previous videos related to the starter solenoid show that the operation/sound is correct with these devices. In fact, I am using 15 out of the 32 outputs on the Power Board: 10 for the contactors and 5 for the Gear, Shaker, Fan, Repeating Bell, and the 12V LED on my Coin Mech, and all of them work fine. But for some reason, something isn't working as it should with the contactors, and the same thing happens with different models, specifically with the: 3RT2017-1BB41, 3RT2016-1BB41, 3RT1015-1BB42, and even with the 3RH1140-1BB40, which is the one you recommend in your bible.
 
Furthermore, if I activate these contactors via the Chime Board, they respond perfectly. I am including links to videos for the ones corresponding to the Flipper (3RT2017-1BB41) and the SlingShot (3RT2016-1BB41):
 
But just like you said, I am also obsessed with getting to the bottom of this. Therefore, I am going to run some tests as well as check impedances and the different components on the power board in case I find something that isn't right or a component/value mounted by mistake.
If I ultimately can't find the source of the problem, I plan to generate a clean pulse with a duration of around 150-200ms (enough to activate the contactors) through a monostable-based circuit from the detection of the first edge at the Power Board output for the bumpers and SlingShots. In addition, I'll use the two available outputs I have on the Chime Board; if I bypass them, I'll be able to maintain full Flipper functionality and take advantage of the installation and wiring already done with minimal alteration.
 
What do you think? Any suggestions or feedback on this alternative?
 
I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this workaround, and as soon as I have any results, I'll share them.
 
Once again Thank you all!


#12 mjr

mjr

    Pinball Wizard

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,346 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 30 September 2026 - 05:34 PM

Therefore, I am going to run some tests as well as check impedances and the different components on the power board in case I find something that isn't right or a component/value mounted by mistake.

 

That seems worth looking into.  It's at least conceivable that the inductance of the contactor coils is creating an LCR filter effect that's optimally bad at the TLC5940 frequency.  It would be a really bizarre coincidence, though, so I really expect there's a simpler explanation, but it's not clear what that is.

 

 

In addition, I'll use the two available outputs I have on the Chime Board; if I bypass them, I'll be able to maintain full Flipper functionality and take advantage of the installation and wiring already done with minimal alteration.

 

If it does turn out to be a TLC5940 PWM frequency interaction, that would certainly fix it.  Are you building the boards yourself, and if so, do you have a spare chime board you haven't built yet?  If so, you could build that board without any of the timers, so you'd have 8 more plain ON/OFF outputs, without any timers or PWM involved.  You can daisy-chain the chime boards, so you can just add it to your existing system.



#13 fhjui

fhjui

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 383 posts
  • Location:Germany

  • Flag: Germany

  • Favorite Pinball: especially EM tables

Posted 01 October 2026 - 08:26 AM

Since the contactors work correctly with the chime board, there seems to be a fault on the power board.

And because the fault affects multiple outputs there, the TLC chip is the likely the culprit.

The outputs 1–16 are controlled via one TLC, and the upper 16 via the second TLC. You can check, if the issue occurs also at the higher outputs.

Unfortunately these TLCs cannot be tested without software (KL25 firmware). But as I described in my document (Troubleshooting_the_Pinscape_Board-EN.pdf) , you can test and measure the stages without a TLC using a simple resistor with 270 Ohm. Therefore the TLCs MUST be in sockets to remove them.

I would suggest to measure the stages at that way by hand, a signal generator isn't necessary.

And a check of the supply voltages at the time of switching on of the outputs is recommended


Edited by fhjui, 01 October 2026 - 08:27 AM.

My documentation for installing vpin software with PinUpsystem (Baller installer): https://mega.nz/fold...wAXZlOEMQGbdutQ

Files and PDF-docu in the subdir "Installation vPin-Software with Baller-Installer"


#14 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 01 October 2026 - 05:59 PM

Since the contactors work correctly with the chime board, there seems to be a fault on the power board.

And because the fault affects multiple outputs there, the TLC chip is the likely the culprit.

The outputs 1–16 are controlled via one TLC, and the upper 16 via the second TLC. You can check, if the issue occurs also at the higher outputs.

Unfortunately these TLCs cannot be tested without software (KL25 firmware). But as I described in my document (Troubleshooting_the_Pinscape_Board-EN.pdf) , you can test and measure the stages without a TLC using a simple resistor with 270 Ohm. Therefore the TLCs MUST be in sockets to remove them.

I would suggest to measure the stages at that way by hand, a signal generator isn't necessary.

And a check of the supply voltages at the time of switching on of the outputs is recommended

 

Hi fhjui,
 
I have tried with different TLCs and they all show the same behavior. Even across both the lower 16 outputs and the upper ones, the fault only appears when I connect a contactor to the outputs.
 
In any case, during my checks over the next few days, I will perform the tests you suggested, since fortunately I have the TLCs mounted on sockets.
 
Thanks for the suggestions, I will keep you updated.


#15 inalambrico

inalambrico

    Neophyte

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 8 posts

  • Flag: Spain

  • Favorite Pinball: The Addams Family

Posted 01 October 2026 - 06:17 PM

 

Therefore, I am going to run some tests as well as check impedances and the different components on the power board in case I find something that isn't right or a component/value mounted by mistake.

 

That seems worth looking into.  It's at least conceivable that the inductance of the contactor coils is creating an LCR filter effect that's optimally bad at the TLC5940 frequency.  It would be a really bizarre coincidence, though, so I really expect there's a simpler explanation, but it's not clear what that is.

 

 

In addition, I'll use the two available outputs I have on the Chime Board; if I bypass them, I'll be able to maintain full Flipper functionality and take advantage of the installation and wiring already done with minimal alteration.

 

If it does turn out to be a TLC5940 PWM frequency interaction, that would certainly fix it.  Are you building the boards yourself, and if so, do you have a spare chime board you haven't built yet?  If so, you could build that board without any of the timers, so you'd have 8 more plain ON/OFF outputs, without any timers or PWM involved.  You can daisy-chain the chime boards, so you can just add it to your existing system.

 

 

Indeed, I’m assembling the boards myself. And besides unfortunately not having an extra Chime Board available, I also don’t have enough space to install one.
 
However, your idea of building a Chime Board without the timers made me realize that I have a better alternative than adding monostables to the outputs of the Power Board to convert it to digital. Since I have an available space of approximately 8x6 cm next to the Power Board outputs, and always with your permission, I could create a timer-less Chime Board MOD that would fit in that space and use it for the contactors. This way, I wouldn’t have to modify anything on the Power Board, other than disconnecting the wiring from the contactor outputs and connecting it to the Chime Board MOD.
 
So, as soon as the components I ordered arrive, I’ll proceed with testing the Power Board and carrying out the checks suggested by fhjui, in case I can identify the problem. If not, I’ll proceed with the new Chimes PCB.
 
Thanks again!


#16 mjr

mjr

    Pinball Wizard

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,346 posts

  • Flag: United States of America

  • Favorite Pinball: Medieval Madness

Posted 01 October 2026 - 07:05 PM

Since I have an available space of approximately 8x6 cm next to the Power Board outputs, and always with your permission, I could create a timer-less Chime Board MOD that would fit in that space and use it for the contactors. This way, I wouldn’t have to modify anything on the Power Board, other than disconnecting the wiring from the contactor outputs and connecting it to the Chime Board MOD.

 

Sounds like a good plan.  You actually don't need to create a whole new "mod" board design, because the Chime Board is already set up to be built without any timers.  No changes are needed to the layout; it's mostly a matter of omitting a bunch of components and installing a couple of bypass resistors instead.  The Build Guide chapter on the expansion board build ("Building the expansion boards") has a section on the changes needed to leave out the timer blocks, which turns the outputs into simple digital output ports.  Building the board without any timer circuits actually makes it a whole lot simpler, because the timer circuits are probably about half of the components on the board.  And like you said, there's no need for extra circuits to "defeat" the timers if you just leave out the timers in the first place.


Scroll down to "Bypassing the timers on the chime board" at the bottom of the "Building the expansion boards" chapter for the details.