- View New Content
-
Getting Started
-
Tutorials
Tutorial Categories
Tutorials Main Page Installation and Setup Downloadable TutorialsROM Adjustments
Number of Balls Adjustments Volume Adjustments
-
Visual Pinball Tables
VP 8 Desktop Tables
All VPM Recreations VP Recreations VP/VPM MODs VP Originals ROMsVP 9 Desktop Tables
All VPM Recreations VP Recreations VP/VPM MODs VP Originals ROMsVP9 Cabinet Tables
All Full Screen Cabinet Full Screen B2S Cabinet Spanned Cabinet Tables Media Packs ROMsVPX Tables
All VPinMAME Recreations VPX- - /VPinMAME - MOD Tables VPX Recreations VPX Originals Media Packs ROMs VR
-
Frontend Media & Backglass
Media Packs
Complete Media Packs Wheel Logos VideosBackglasses
dB2S Animated Backglasses UVP Animated Backglasses Topper Images
- Future Pinball Tables
-
Design Resources
Main Resources
Table Templates Playfield Images Image Library Sound Library Key CodesVP Guides
VP8 Guide - English VP8 Guide - Deutsch VP9 Guide - English VP9.1.x Guide - English VP Object Guide VPM DocumentationFuture Pinball Resources
Playfield Images 3D Model LibraryFuture Pinball Guides
FP Script Guide Big Draco Script Guide FP Table Design Guide FP DMD Guide
- Other Features
- Bug Tracker
- Image Gallery
- Blogs
-
More
Dual Monitor support..
Started By
Rawd
, Apr 19 2011 04:09 PM
92 replies to this topic
#81
Posted 14 December 2011 - 07:09 PM
Has there been any further developement on NATIVE multi-monitor support in VP? This is a very useful feature and would take VP to even greater heights!
Secondly, Is there a development list of what the VP development team is working on? I would love hear whats gettig focus in teh next version of Vp. Go DEVELOPMENT!
Secondly, Is there a development list of what the VP development team is working on? I would love hear whats gettig focus in teh next version of Vp. Go DEVELOPMENT!
#82
Posted 14 December 2011 - 07:20 PM
im wondering if there are still developers around. i haven't seem toxie or cupid posting
"it will all be ok in the end, if it's not ok, it's not the end"
Monster Bash VP10 WIP https://dl.dropboxus... (vpx)WIP15.vpx
#83
Posted 14 December 2011 - 07:48 PM
Cupid's last log in was 20th June 2011 - 02:27 PM
Toxie logged in yesterday
Manofwar last logged in 17th July 2011 - 04:08 PM
Manofwar actually has backglass support for VP, I think it even worked for some people, for me it crashes when I try to play the table, but I could build the backglass and the table loaded and the backdrop (backglass) looked beautiful sitting on the second screen with reels and everything, I just couldn't hit the 1 key to play the table or it crashed.
The version I tried even had a new plunger (by Rascal) in it that was pretty cool.
Maybe Rosve would know how to work with the source in regards to multiple monitor support. The problem is, it is over most of our heads and the guys capable of doing this work could just as easily spend their free making money for this type of work.
Toxie logged in yesterday
Manofwar last logged in 17th July 2011 - 04:08 PM
Manofwar actually has backglass support for VP, I think it even worked for some people, for me it crashes when I try to play the table, but I could build the backglass and the table loaded and the backdrop (backglass) looked beautiful sitting on the second screen with reels and everything, I just couldn't hit the 1 key to play the table or it crashed.
Maybe Rosve would know how to work with the source in regards to multiple monitor support. The problem is, it is over most of our heads and the guys capable of doing this work could just as easily spend their free making money for this type of work.

You have discovered an Easter egg. Pat yourself on the back.
#84
Posted 14 December 2011 - 07:58 PM
i had that one too bob. same issue. looked great till i hit one.
"it will all be ok in the end, if it's not ok, it's not the end"
Monster Bash VP10 WIP https://dl.dropboxus... (vpx)WIP15.vpx
#85
Posted 23 February 2012 - 06:35 AM
I know this is a really old post, but I was wondering if maybe I can help. I agree that this needs to be integrated into VP, I've done dx programming and a dual screen app or two and in theory at least, it isn't hard to implement.
It's true that dx7 isn't the best version. What I would suggest is a hybrid of dx7/dx8. You can load textures and such via the old dx7 calls but let dx8 handle the actual rendering. They are designed to work fairly well together.
There isn't any benefit in upgrading any further though DX gives you new toolsets, so unless somebody wants to implement all kinds of crazy stuff in the engine there is no benefit. Also if you upgrade beyond dx9, xp users will have trouble running vp.
Multiple render targets are tricky if the two monitors don't share the same resolution or bit-depth though.
There are simplier ways to do it though. One of the easiest ways is to just not render in fullscreen mode. You can remove the borders and such and get an image on both monitors simply by making the window wider and/or longer than the resolution of the primary monitor. Unless one monitor has hw/accel and the other doesn't, there should be virtually no performance hit between two fullscreen renders on multiple targets and a simple windowed render stretched across two monitors. The thing is, you can't simply make a backglass to the left and be done with it. VP would need options to let you set the resolution and position of both monitors. Vp would then calculate the total resolution of both monitors and scale/position the dmd on the portion of the render window that's displayed on the backglass monitor, taking into account differences in resolution when scaling the backglass.
I might be able to rig up a demo just by monkeying with vp's registry options for the second one. The spanned tables are already setup this way, you just need to stretch that window so that they can... well be spanned.
#86
Posted 23 February 2012 - 07:17 AM
**Update**
I looked into it and VP doesn't even run in true fullscreen, which is a good thing! As many of you probably already know, you can "trick" a spanned table to span multiple monitors if you simply pre-activate your secondary monitor, place it below the primary and double the height of the resolution via registry editing. This is a MUCH simplier way to do it so I think everyone is looking at the problem the wrong way. Multiple render targets aren't needed... what is needed is a bounding box to define the table area, and another to define the backglass area. By changing the size of the window and moving and scaling the backglass area it should be possible to position the backglass on any secondary monitor despite resolution differences.
Vp just needs some more options as I said earlier. It needs to be able to set the bitdepth and resolution of each monitor independantly and sense where the secondary monitor is. This isn't hard to pull off at all. If it knows these three things it can compensate for size and position differences and adjust things accordingly.
I looked into it and VP doesn't even run in true fullscreen, which is a good thing! As many of you probably already know, you can "trick" a spanned table to span multiple monitors if you simply pre-activate your secondary monitor, place it below the primary and double the height of the resolution via registry editing. This is a MUCH simplier way to do it so I think everyone is looking at the problem the wrong way. Multiple render targets aren't needed... what is needed is a bounding box to define the table area, and another to define the backglass area. By changing the size of the window and moving and scaling the backglass area it should be possible to position the backglass on any secondary monitor despite resolution differences.
Vp just needs some more options as I said earlier. It needs to be able to set the bitdepth and resolution of each monitor independantly and sense where the secondary monitor is. This isn't hard to pull off at all. If it knows these three things it can compensate for size and position differences and adjust things accordingly.
#88
Posted 23 February 2012 - 08:05 AM
QUOTE (Dazz @ Feb 23 2012, 02:54 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Isn't spanning only available in XP? There is a specific reason as to why we moved away from spanned tables, but I don't recall.
Nah... spanning works on windows ME or later... I'm running win 7.
I can think of some reasons why you guys would run into issues from spanning (they are all fixable) but I'll wait for you guys to let me know what issues you were having.
#89
Posted 23 February 2012 - 09:02 AM
great news howard! good luck with it.
there is already one two screen patch from manofwar floating around, did you check how he did that? was it also one window spread across desktop?
Nah... spanning works on windows ME or later... I'm running win 7.
I can think of some reasons why you guys would run into issues from spanning (they are all fixable) but I'll wait for you guys to let me know what issues you were having.
This is not spanning - spanning is when you see whole desktop as one big screen. It was abandoned cause after winxp there is no suport for it in windows display settings.
This scenario uses normal multi screen desktop - only difference from full screen vp would be that all monitors (second and possibly third) will be initialized so for example you could move playfield to any of them just by changing scale and offset.
Of course some calculation should be done so that pf goes to most left screen, and bg to the next one to the right.
there is already one two screen patch from manofwar floating around, did you check how he did that? was it also one window spread across desktop?
QUOTE (HowardC @ Feb 23 2012, 09:05 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
QUOTE (Dazz @ Feb 23 2012, 02:54 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Isn't spanning only available in XP? There is a specific reason as to why we moved away from spanned tables, but I don't recall.
Nah... spanning works on windows ME or later... I'm running win 7.
I can think of some reasons why you guys would run into issues from spanning (they are all fixable) but I'll wait for you guys to let me know what issues you were having.
This is not spanning - spanning is when you see whole desktop as one big screen. It was abandoned cause after winxp there is no suport for it in windows display settings.
This scenario uses normal multi screen desktop - only difference from full screen vp would be that all monitors (second and possibly third) will be initialized so for example you could move playfield to any of them just by changing scale and offset.
Of course some calculation should be done so that pf goes to most left screen, and bg to the next one to the right.
My paper cab
core.vbs with better nudge
FPLaunch with exit menu, instructions, flyer - local vpf copy
VP with support for analog nudge and plunger with any gamepad
#90
Posted 23 February 2012 - 06:54 PM
Ahh... I see the confusion then... it's a matter of symantics. When I think spanned I think "extended desktop" when you guys are talking about spanned you are talking about that cazy setting where you can make two monitors work as one big one. Never cared for that myself, seemed to defeat the purpose of having two monitors.
But yeah, what I'm talking about is extended desktop mode.
I tried manowar's exe but it crashed on me. I haven't looked at the patch yet, but I think he's using dual render targets. My guess is it's going to teach me alot about how vp is rendering things, so it'll be useful regardless.
vp pre-renders everything right? That would mean that the positioning would have to be done ahead of time. Not a big deal or anything, but I'll have to keep that in mind.
Understand that it's going to be a while before I can look into it though... I've got other things on the stove. I'll certainly give it a try asap though.
But yeah, what I'm talking about is extended desktop mode.
I tried manowar's exe but it crashed on me. I haven't looked at the patch yet, but I think he's using dual render targets. My guess is it's going to teach me alot about how vp is rendering things, so it'll be useful regardless.
vp pre-renders everything right? That would mean that the positioning would have to be done ahead of time. Not a big deal or anything, but I'll have to keep that in mind.
Understand that it's going to be a while before I can look into it though... I've got other things on the stove. I'll certainly give it a try asap though.
#91
Posted 23 February 2012 - 11:36 PM
Anything you do is appreciated. Thanks for looking into this.
I think VP renders the playfield at the start, and then each time a light is turned on or off. (someone correct me if I'm wrong)
I think VP renders the playfield at the start, and then each time a light is turned on or off. (someone correct me if I'm wrong)
QUOTE (HowardC @ Feb 23 2012, 11:54 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Ahh... I see the confusion then... it's a matter of symantics. When I think spanned I think "extended desktop" when you guys are talking about spanned you are talking about that cazy setting where you can make two monitors work as one big one. Never cared for that myself, seemed to defeat the purpose of having two monitors.
But yeah, what I'm talking about is extended desktop mode.
I tried manowar's exe but it crashed on me. I haven't looked at the patch yet, but I think he's using dual render targets. My guess is it's going to teach me alot about how vp is rendering things, so it'll be useful regardless.
vp pre-renders everything right? That would mean that the positioning would have to be done ahead of time. Not a big deal or anything, but I'll have to keep that in mind.
Understand that it's going to be a while before I can look into it though... I've got other things on the stove. I'll certainly give it a try asap though.
But yeah, what I'm talking about is extended desktop mode.
I tried manowar's exe but it crashed on me. I haven't looked at the patch yet, but I think he's using dual render targets. My guess is it's going to teach me alot about how vp is rendering things, so it'll be useful regardless.
vp pre-renders everything right? That would mean that the positioning would have to be done ahead of time. Not a big deal or anything, but I'll have to keep that in mind.
Understand that it's going to be a while before I can look into it though... I've got other things on the stove. I'll certainly give it a try asap though.



Top
















are all trademarks of VPFORUMS.